When You Cut Off Your Mother After Your Children Already Love Her

How an abusive parent uses the role of the "fun grandmother" to rewrite family history, and why protecting your peace later can cost you a relationship with your own child.

When You Cut Off Your Mother After Your Children Already Love Her

A lot of women who were mistreated by their mothers don't stop speaking to them at twenty-five. At twenty-five there's a baby on the way. She was a hard mother, the thinking goes, but she might be a better grandmother, and the children deserve Sunday dinners and somebody in the audience at the school play besides their parents. So the woman lets the comments about her weight go at every one of those dinners, and the ones about her husband's job. Her children get a grandmother out of it.

Her mother doesn't turn into someone else when the grandchildren arrive. She does get a role with fewer obligations than the one she had before, since a grandmother doesn't have to enforce bedtimes or sit through math homework. She buys the $200 tablet her daughter already said no to, she gives the children soda an hour before dinner, and she tells them not to tell their mother. Their mother gets so worked up about everything. To a seven-year-old, Grandma is the one who says yes and Mom is the one who says no, and nobody has explained to her that the rules were Mom's and Grandma broke them on purpose.

The Grandmother Exemption

When the oldest is fourteen and furious about a curfew, her grandmother doesn't back up her mother. She listens and sighs and says that her mother has always been anxious, even as a little girl, and that she can always talk to Grandma, since Grandma doesn't yell. The fourteen-year-old has no way of knowing what her grandmother was like in 1988, and her mother decided a long time ago that she wouldn't tell a child what her own mother did. So the grandmother's account goes unanswered for years, and the granddaughter starts to see her mother the way her grandmother describes her.

Eventually the grandmother does something her daughter can't let go. At her granddaughter's high school graduation party, she tells a table of relatives that her daughter has always been jealous of her and was a difficult child, where the graduate could hear it. Her daughter, who's been letting things go for seventeen years, stops returning her calls after that.

To a sixteen-year-old or a twenty-year-old, it looks like her mother cut off a seventy-four-year-old woman who sent her fifty dollars every birthday and listened to her talk about her boyfriend. She didn't see the forty years before the graduation party, and she only heard the one remark.

When the grandmother tells relatives she has no idea what she did wrong, the granddaughter believes her, since nothing she's personally seen gives her a reason not to.

The Secret Alliance

The cutoff doesn't hold for the granddaughter. She keeps texting her grandmother and meets her for lunch every few weeks without telling her mother. At each lunch she hears again how much her grandmother misses her mother and how unfair it all is. The secrecy becomes evidence for her grandmother's side, because having to hide the lunches seems to prove her mother is the one who can't be reasoned with.

Years later, at twenty-seven, the granddaughter has a baby of her own and asks her mother to watch him four days a week so she can go back to work. Her mother says she can do two, because she's still working herself. A disagreement like that might get talked through in another family. Here the daughter already has an explanation for her mother ready, the one her grandmother gave her at fourteen, that her mother is controlling and impossible to please. She stops answering her mother's calls, and she's sure she's the one getting away from the difficult person in the family.

Addressing the Cycle

A mother in this position is going to want to decide her daughter was turned against her, and the grandmother's comments did shape how her daughter sees her. Her daughter also lived with her for eighteen years, though, and saw some things for herself. Some of what she's angry about might belong to her mother and have nothing to do with the grandmother. If her mother puts the whole estrangement down to the grandmother's influence, she won't hear those parts when her daughter finally says them.

If this happened to you, you've probably spent a lot of nights wishing you'd stopped speaking to your mother at twenty-five. At twenty-five you had a baby coming and a mother who hadn't yet had the chance to show you what kind of grandmother she'd be, and you made the call you could with what you knew. If your daughter brings up her grandmother, don't go through what she did to you in 1988, because to your daughter it'll sound like you're still angry at a woman she loves. You can tell her that you know her grandmother was good to her and you're glad she had that, that it was different for you, and that you'd rather talk about the two of you, and then let it drop. You can't take back the years your mother spent with your children, and you don't have to apologize for finally stopping.

Are you a mother trying to navigate this double estrangement?

Was I Really That Bad?

A Thoughtful Guide for Mothers Facing Adult Child Estrangement

This book looks closely at how a parent and child can remember the same years differently, and how to approach reconciliation without repeating the triangulation you experienced.

Explore the book →
Dr. Keisha Clark

Dr. Clark is a developmental psychologist specializing in intergenerational estrangement and family dynamics. Her work explores how estrangement shapes identity, relationships, and boundary formation over time. Drawing from both research and lived experience, she writes about the complexities of family relationships with clarity, honesty, and depth.

https://www.TheEstrangementProject.com
Previous
Previous

Saying Yes at Work Before You've Looked at Your Calendar

Next
Next

How Much Help Is Too Much to Ask of a Daughter