Why Sharing Good News Feels Risky

Why growing up in a difficult family trains you to hide your accomplishments, and how to stop downplaying your joy around people who actually want to celebrate with you.

Why Sharing Good News Feels Risky

You get a job offer and wait a month to tell your family, and when you finally bring it up you leave out the salary and add that you're not sure how well you'll do. You might call yourself a private person, and maybe you are, but you also know which questions your family will ask and how often something you're pleased about has turned into a conversation you didn't want to have.

That habit usually comes from ordinary moments that happened often enough for you to expect them. You brought home a good report card and a parent started talking about your brother's trouble at school, and you were expected to understand that celebrating your grades would make him feel worse. You mentioned something else you were excited about and were told not to get ahead of yourself. After enough of that you started saying less, and you probably didn't notice you were doing it.

Defending Your Joy in Advance

By adulthood you might be leaving things out before anyone has responded. You tell your family about the promotion and explain right away that the raise isn't much. You book a trip and don't mention it until you're back, because you don't want to defend what you spent on it.

Even when nobody criticizes you, you've prepared an explanation in advance.

You might also be paying for things you'd rather not pay for because accepting help has caused problems before. Your mother offers to pay for the movers and you say no, because the last time she helped she brought it up during arguments afterward. You pay the $1,800 yourself so that you don't have to have those conversations again, and someone who hasn't had that experience might not understand why you'd turn down the money.

When the Habit Affects Safe Relationships

You can end up expecting the same reaction from people who've never reacted that way. A close friend hears about your promotion from someone else and wants to know why you didn't tell her, or a partner finds out you've been happy about something for weeks without mentioning it. You weren't trying to leave either of them out, but they can still be hurt that you didn't want them to know.

Keeping things to yourself made sense with people who responded to good news with criticism or a request for a loan, since you learned what happened when you shared and adjusted how much you told them. A friend who has been glad for you every time has given you different information, though, and it's fair to ask whether you're keeping your news from her because of how she treats you or because of how your family treated you.

Sharing Without the Disclaimers

You can start with someone who's been kind about your news before and tell them something good without explaining why it isn't a big deal. If you're happy about the raise, you can tell them that. You don't have to share the amount, and being more open with a friend doesn't require telling your family anything more than you already do. You can keep as much privacy as you want and still let the people you trust know when something good happens.

Are you ready to stop managing everyone else's reactions?

Useful Isn't the Same as Loved

How to Stop Over-Functioning in Your Relationships and at Work

This book explores where a daughter learns to keep everyone else comfortable before herself, why you downplay your own joy to keep the peace, and how to start claiming your successes without the disclaimers.

Explore the book →
Dr. Keisha Clark

Dr. Clark is a developmental psychologist specializing in intergenerational estrangement and family dynamics. Her work explores how estrangement shapes identity, relationships, and boundary formation over time. Drawing from both research and lived experience, she writes about the complexities of family relationships with clarity, honesty, and depth.

https://www.TheEstrangementProject.com
Previous
Previous

Is It Okay to Laugh About Your Mother?

Next
Next

Saying Yes at Work Before You've Looked at Your Calendar