Why the boundaries you set with your family will inevitably disrupt your oldest friendships, and how the people you chose at sixteen reflect the love you were taught to accept.
A year or two after a woman stops going to her mother's house, she might notice her oldest friend has started to bother her. Her friend makes a joke about her weight in front of people at dinner, or cancels the afternoon of, after the sitter's already been paid. Two summers ago the friend borrowed four hundred dollars and hasn't mentioned it since, and the calls come when the friend's car is in the shop or her marriage is going badly, with nothing in between. None of it is new, because her friend has done all of it since they were in high school, and for most of those years she laughed along or let it go.
Choosing What We Know
She chose her friend using what her family taught her. A child learns what closeness looks like from the people who raise her. If a girl's mother criticized her clothes and her grades and called it honesty, a friend who did the same felt like somebody who cared enough to tell her the truth. In a family where love meant being needed, a friend who needed rides and money felt like a close friend. She was sixteen when they met, and her friend treated her the way she already expected to be treated.
Her friend hasn't changed in twenty years, and she has. Once she stopped taking the criticism and the one-way favors from her family, she couldn't keep taking them from anybody else. She spent years figuring out that the comments about her body weren't jokes and that people who only call when they need something aren't close to her, and she can't know it about her mother and then forget it when her friend picks up the phone.
The friendship lasted twenty years because she did the work in it. She drove her friend to the airport and lent her money, and when her friend's apartment was too small for the children's birthday parties, she hosted them. Her friend talked for two hours about the divorce, and she got ten minutes about her own job before the friend had to go. All of it came easily, because she'd been doing the same work for her family since she was a child.
When Setting a Boundary Looks Like Changing
When she starts saying no, her friend might tell her she's changed, that she thinks she's better than everybody now or she's been reading too much on the internet. A few friends go further and defend the mother, and remind her she only gets one. Her family said the same things when she stopped doing what they expected. Like her family, the friend liked her better when she never said no, because a woman who never says no is easier to have around.
Losing the friend can make her doubt the whole decision. Inside a couple of years she's stopped speaking to her family and ended her oldest friendship. Her family already says she's the problem, that she's cold and can't get along with anyone, so a second loss looks like proof.
It's easy to start thinking that if everybody leaves, the common factor is her.
The Same Lesson Closing Twice
What her family and her friend have in common is where she learned to choose people. She picked her friends by what her family taught her about how people treat each other, so when she changed her mind about how she should be treated, it changed for every relationship she'd chosen the old way. Her family and her oldest friend came from the same lesson, and it makes sense for both to end within a few years of each other. The friends she makes after this, she'll be choosing with a better idea of how a friend should treat her.
People will bring up the twenty years as if the number settles it. Her friend was in her wedding and knew her grandmother, and leaving someone who's been around that long is harder than leaving a woman she met at work three years ago. Twenty years is how long the friendship lasted, and for nearly all of it she was the one driving to the airport and listening to the divorce.
Ending the friendship means losing the one person left who knew her at sixteen. She'll probably have a stretch with fewer people in her life than she's ever had, with no family at the holidays and no best friend to call about it. New friends take time, and they take longer to make with a job and children than they did in high school.
Before you end it, find out whether she can change. Some old friends do once you tell them what you won't do anymore, because they were going along with what they saw you put up with. Ask her to stop making comments about your weight, or tell her you can't lend money again, and watch what she does next. A friend who can adjust will be embarrassed and awkward for a few weeks, and then she'll start asking how you've been and listening to the answer. One who can't will keep telling you that you used to be more fun.
Are you noticing the same dynamics in your friendships?
Useful Isn't the Same as Loved
How to Stop Over-Functioning in Your Relationships and at Work
This book explores the work a family assigns to a daughter, how she keeps doing that work for friends and partners long after she's left home, and why withdrawing your over-functioning often forces relationships to either adapt or end.